Why Can’t I Stop Thinking About the Life I Could Have Had?
REGRET
What you’re feeling:
A recurring ache about the choices you made — and the possibilities you left behind.
How it may be showing up:
You find yourself replaying old decisions or imagining another version of your life: the career you didn’t pursue, the place you didn’t move to, the relationship that ended, or the thing you thought you would do one day.
Why it may make sense in midlife:
As time becomes more visible, paths that once felt as though they would always remain possible can come back into focus. You can value the life you have and still feel something for possibilities that were never lived.
One practical place to begin:
Ask: When I imagine the life I could have lived, what am I really longing for now?
Perhaps it happens while you’re scrolling one evening.
You see someone living somewhere you once imagined living, doing work you once thought you might do, or starting something you told yourself you would do one day.
Suddenly another version of your life becomes surprisingly vivid.
What if you had taken that job? Moved away? Stayed? Left? Chosen differently?
Then comes the uncomfortable thought:
Did I make the wrong choices?
That can be especially unsettling when the life you actually have is good.
You may love the people in it, be grateful for what you have built, and still find yourself wondering about another path.
Every life takes shape through choices. Choosing one direction inevitably means other possibilities are left behind.
In midlife, with enough life behind us to see the path we have taken, some of those unlived possibilities can become more emotionally visible.
HOW YOUR BRAIN MAY BE MAKING SENSE OF IT
Psychologists call our ability to imagine alternatives to what actually happened counterfactual thinking.
It is the kind of thinking behind the what if… if only… and I wonder what would have happened if… versions of our past.
This can help us learn from experience. But it can also make an unlived possibility feel vivid.
And the imagined life is incomplete. We can picture the freedom, creativity or adventure it might have contained without knowing the disappointments, compromises and ordinary difficulties that would have existed there too.
So imagining another life is not, by itself, proof that you chose the wrong one.
It may simply mean that a possibility you once imagined still carries emotional meaning.
From the work of psychologist Neal Roese on counterfactual thinking.
One practical place to begin
The more useful question may not be:
Should I have chosen another life?
It may be:
What does that imagined life represent to me now?
Perhaps the city represents freedom. The career represents creativity. The travelling represents adventure. The woman you imagine becoming represents independence, confidence or being seen.
You cannot go back and live every path.
But you can become curious about whether something from an unlived path still deserves a place in your life now.
ASK
When I imagine the life I could have lived, what am I really longing for?
ACT
Name one quality — freedom, creativity, adventure, purpose, belonging, learning or independence — and give it one small expression this week.
NOTICE
What happens to the thought “I chose the wrong life”?
Does it soften? Does the longing become clearer? Does it show you something that still matters?
There is no correct response. You are gathering information about the woman you are now.
Maybe what you’re experiencing makes sense.
One ordinary moment at a time.
Not sure where to begin?
The free Midlife, Understood™ 5-Minute Check-In can help you notice which part of life may need your attention—and find one practical place to begin.
You may recognise these Moments too …
You stood in the supermarket… and realised you couldn't answer a simple question.
Sometimes we spend so many years responding to everyone else's needs that we slowly lose touch with our own.
You looked at the calendar… and suddenly realised how quickly the last ten years had disappeared.
Sometimes it's not age that changes us.
It's the realisation that time has become more precious than it once felt.
